OnDMARC vs. DMARCIAN: What's the difference?

With domains often targeted by cyber threats, implementing DMARC (Domain-based Message Authentication, Reporting & Conformance) is essential for protecting your brand and enhancing email deliverability. But which service should you choose? In this article, we explore how OnDMARC (provided by 101domain) compares to DMARCIAN.


The Key Difference: Dynamic SPF and DKIM Management

When it comes to email authentication, SPF (Sender Policy Framework) and DKIM (DomainKeys Identified Mail) are crucial components in preventing unauthorized use of your domain. OnDMARC distinguishes itself with its advanced capabilities for Dynamic SPF and DKIM management, offering features that DMARCIAN does not provide. 

Here’s a detailed look at these key advantages.


Dynamic SPF Management

  • OnDMARC: Yes
  • DMARCIAN: No

SPF Record Limitations and Challenges:

SPF records specify which mail servers are permitted to send emails on behalf of your domain. However, there is a technical limitation—an SPF lookup limit of 10 DNS queries. Exceeding this limit can cause your SPF to fail, leading to delivery issues and vulnerabilities in your email authentication.

Solution – Dynamic SPF Management:

OnDMARC’s Dynamic SPF management addresses these challenges by automatically optimizing and managing your SPF records. Instead of manually curating your SPF entries, Dynamic SPF streamlines this process by restructuring the DNS queries to stay within the RFC limits. This intelligent handling reduces the risk of misconfigurations and ensures that your emails consistently pass SPF checks.

Benefits:

  • Reduced Manual Intervention: Dynamic SPF automates complex tasks, allowing your IT team to focus on other priorities.
  • Improved Deliverability: By managing SPF records effectively, OnDMARC helps prevent delivery failures and ensures your emails reach their intended recipients.
  • Enhanced Security: Maintains a robust authentication framework, defending against unauthorized email senders.

Dynamic DKIM Management

  • OnDMARC: Yes
  • DMARCIAN: No

Understanding DKIM:

DKIM adds a digital signature to emails, allowing recipients to verify that the email hasn’t been tampered with in transit. It is a critical layer of protection that ensures the integrity of your email content.

Dynamic DKIM Management:

While managing DKIM can often be complex due to the need to regularly update keys and policies, OnDMARC simplifies this with its Dynamic DKIM management. This feature automates the rotation and maintenance of DKIM keys, minimizing the risk of outdated configurations that could undermine your email security.

Benefits:

  • Ease of Use: Automatically handles DKIM setup and maintenance, alleviating the technical burden on your team.
  • Security Assurance: Regular key rotation and automated updates bolstered by Dynamic DKIM management enhance your domain’s reputation and trustworthiness.
  • Consistency and Reliability: Ensure consistent application of DKIM across all outgoing emails, reinforcing the security of your communications.

Fully Managed Service

  • OnDMARC: Yes
  • DMARCIAN: No

Simplified DMARC Management:

OnDMARC’s fully managed service distinguishes itself by offering comprehensive support for businesses seeking to outsource the intricacies of DMARC configuration. This service means that an expert team manages all aspects of your DMARC implementation, from setup to continuous monitoring and adjustments.

Compared to DMARCIAN, which leans towards a self-service model, OnDMARC’s fully managed approach offers peace of mind, knowing that professionals are dedicated to overseeing your email security.

Benefits:

  • Reduced Overhead: With less need for in-house technical expertise, businesses can allocate resources to other priorities.
  • Streamlined Processes: OnDMARC simplifies workflows by integrating domain and email management.
  • Expert Support: Gain access to the 101domain solutions team that actively oversees your DMARC posture, ensuring optimal performance and security.

Cost-Effective Pricing

Competitive Edge in Pricing:

OnDMARC often emerges as the more cost-effective choice compared to DMARCIAN and other competitors. By delivering a comprehensive suite of features bundled with domain services, OnDMARC provides excellent value without compromising on quality or security.

Benefits:

  • Bundled Services: Consolidating domain and email management under a single platform can lead to significant cost savings.
  • Value for Money: With advanced features like Dynamic SPF and DKIM included, OnDMARC offers a full-featured solution at an attractive price point.
  • Scalable Solutions: Businesses of all sizes can find a fitting plan that aligns with their budgetary constraints.

Conclusion

While DMARCIAN offers a solid toolset, organizations that prefer a worry-free, expertly managed solution may find greater value in OnDMARC. At 101domain, we’ve partnered with OnDMARC to be able to provide this tool as a fully managed service. Consider reaching out to experience firsthand the benefits that OnDMARC can bring to your organization’s email authentication strategy.

Need Help With Your DMARC Setup?

Learn more about 101domain’s Managed DMARC Services and let us do the heavy lifting for you. We handle policy setup, monitoring, and reporting so you can rest easy knowing your emails are secure.